Meme Answers Part 1 (& Tredegar House)
Sep. 2nd, 2019 07:03 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
smallhobbitFirst of all my answers to stonepicnicking_okapi who asked me these questions:
#4: What's better (or the least bad), character over plot or plot over character?
Plot every time. A good plot will excuse somewhat dodgy characters - if they are totally OOC, then no. If the plot is poor then no matter how good the characters I will be bored.
#21: Would you like to write an alternative ending for any of your favourite shows/books/etc
I write fanfic, of course I would. Which isn't to say I don't think the ending was right in its own way. My Hobbit fics are Everyone Lives/No-one Dies and yet I think Thorin's death is entirely appropriate in the book/film.
#19: Do you think major character deaths are ever appropriate.
This was asked rather tongue in cheek, since I had just killed Watson for most of JWP this year. Even disregarding this, yes, I do. Death is a fact of life. On the whole I do prefer to keep my characters alive - I write Spooks fics, where both my main charactors died in canon. But if I write a war fic I will not guarantee my characters will survive, because wars kill. I have let both Holmes and Watson die at the end of a long life, which has been bittersweet. So yes, used correctly I do think major character deaths are appropriate.
Full list of questions is here.
On Saturday we went to visit Tredegar House. It was an enjoyable last day out of the summer:
stonepicnicking_okapi who asked me these questions:#4: What's better (or the least bad), character over plot or plot over character?
Plot every time. A good plot will excuse somewhat dodgy characters - if they are totally OOC, then no. If the plot is poor then no matter how good the characters I will be bored.
#21: Would you like to write an alternative ending for any of your favourite shows/books/etc
I write fanfic, of course I would. Which isn't to say I don't think the ending was right in its own way. My Hobbit fics are Everyone Lives/No-one Dies and yet I think Thorin's death is entirely appropriate in the book/film.
#19: Do you think major character deaths are ever appropriate.
This was asked rather tongue in cheek, since I had just killed Watson for most of JWP this year. Even disregarding this, yes, I do. Death is a fact of life. On the whole I do prefer to keep my characters alive - I write Spooks fics, where both my main charactors died in canon. But if I write a war fic I will not guarantee my characters will survive, because wars kill. I have let both Holmes and Watson die at the end of a long life, which has been bittersweet. So yes, used correctly I do think major character deaths are appropriate.
Full list of questions is here.
~~~
On Saturday we went to visit Tredegar House. It was an enjoyable last day out of the summer:
no subject
Date: 2019-09-05 08:55 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2019-09-05 08:58 pm (UTC)